The Ultimate Guide to One-Ingredient Cherry Ice Cream: Simple, Healthy, and Delicious

As cherry season bursts forth, painting our local markets with vibrant shades of ruby red, there’s an undeniable urge to revel in their fleeting beauty and exquisite taste. For many, this means consuming as many fresh cherries as humanly possible. I typically embrace this joyous ritual by stocking up on a bountiful supply, often somewhere between sixty and eighty pounds, from my wonderful Amish friends. While we enthusiastically indulge in fresh cherries and dedicate time to making luscious jams, there comes a point where even the most ardent cherry lover seeks alternative, creative ways to preserve and enjoy this seasonal treasure. This is where the magic of one-ingredient cherry ice cream truly shines.

To extend the delight of cherry season far beyond its natural window, I always make sure to freeze a significant portion—at least twenty pounds—of these beautiful little red orbs. This generous stash allows us to whip up what my boys (both the ones I brought into the world and the one I married) affectionately, if somewhat un-elegantly, call “Fruit Poop.” While every fiber of my being as a food enthusiast resists such a moniker, I must admit, they have a point. This incredibly simple, single-ingredient ice cream (as I prefer to call it) is crafted using a juicer fitted with its blank plate. As the juicer’s auger gently turns, it extrudes—or, to use the boys’ less refined term, “poops”—the frozen fruit into a perfectly smooth, soft-serve dessert. My trusty Champion Juicer, a cherished gift from my beloved stepmom Valerie, holds a special place in my heart, as it was Valerie who first introduced me to the ingenious concept of transforming frozen fruit into such a delightful treat. While I’ve since discovered that an excellent version can be made with a powerful food processor or a robust blender, I maintain a soft spot for the traditional juicer method, a testament to Val’s culinary wisdom.

Why One-Ingredient Cherry Ice Cream is a Must-Try

This deceptively simple recipe offers a plethora of benefits that extend beyond its ease of preparation. Firstly, it’s a beacon of health. Made exclusively from sweet cherries, it contains no added sugars, dairy, or artificial ingredients, making it a perfect choice for those with dietary restrictions, seeking a healthier lifestyle, or simply wanting to enjoy the pure, unadulterated flavor of fruit. Cherries themselves are packed with antioxidants, vitamins, and anti-inflammatory compounds, making this dessert not just delicious but also incredibly nourishing. Secondly, it’s remarkably quick. With pre-frozen cherries, you can go from craving to a creamy, satisfying dessert in mere minutes. This makes it an ideal last-minute treat for unexpected guests or a spontaneous indulgence on a hot summer day. Finally, its versatility is unmatched. Whether you enjoy it as a soft-serve immediately, harden it for scoopable ice cream, or transform it into vibrant fruit pops, this recipe adapts to your preferences, providing a guilt-free pleasure everyone can enjoy.

Mastering the Art of Freezing Cherries: The IQF Method

Have you ever tried freezing sweet cherries? It’s astonishingly simple, yet crucial for achieving the best results for your one-ingredient ice cream and other frozen cherry endeavors. The secret lies in a technique known as ‘IQF,’ or Individually Quick Frozen. This method ensures each cherry freezes separately, preventing them from clumping together into an unwieldy block.

Step-by-Step IQF Cherry Freezing:

1. Pit the Cherries: This is the most labor-intensive step, but it’s worth it. Use a hand pitter or a plunger pitter for efficiency. If you don’t have one, a clean, narrow-tipped icing or pastry bag tip can be used to push the pits out with your finger.
2. Arrange on a Pan: Spread the pitted cherries in a single layer on a rimmed baking sheet. Lining the pan with foil or a silicone baking mat (silpat) is highly recommended, as it makes removing the frozen cherries much easier.
3. Freeze Solid: Place the entire pan in your freezer and let the cherries freeze until they are completely solid. This usually takes a few hours, depending on your freezer’s temperature.
4. Bag and Store: Once thoroughly frozen, remove the pan from the freezer. Gently lift the foil or silpat to help dislodge the cherries. Quickly transfer the loose, frozen cherries into resealable freezer bags. Press out as much air as possible before sealing. Label the bags with the date.
5. Return to Freezer: Place the bags back into the freezer immediately to prevent any thawing and refreezing, which can lead to larger ice crystals and a less desirable texture. Stored correctly, your IQF cherries can last for up to a year.

You might wonder, why bother with IQF? Why not just dump pitted cherries into a freezer bag? If you skip the individual freezing step, you’ll end up with a giant, impenetrable block of frozen cherries. While a cherry ice block might be novel for a punch bowl, it’s incredibly inconvenient for everyday use. Imagine trying to chip off a small portion for a smoothie or a handful for your steel-cut oats! IQF cherries, on the other hand, offer unparalleled convenience. You can simply open a bag, reach in for exactly the amount you need, and the rest remain perfectly loose and ready for future use. My plans often involve simply eating a handful of these frosty delights straight from the bag, but perhaps that’s just my personal indulgence.

I would absolutely love to show you a pristine picture of my perfectly IQF-frozen cherries, but a recent refrigerator and freezer malfunction over a scorching weekend resulted in my beautiful individual cherries morphing into a single, sorrowful block when I hurried to stash the partially thawed babies into the chest freezer. Le sigh. At least I still have them, along with an ice pick. EEEE EEEE EEEE EEEE EEE EEEE (that’s my text version of horror music, echoing through the empty freezer shelves).

One-Ingredient Cherry Ice Cream Recipe

You don’t have to miss out on fabulous desserts when you’re trying to eat healthy! Sweet cherries are the star (and only!) ingredient in this fantastic pure-fruit ice cream that comes together in moments when you have cherries in your freezer. Instructions for individually freezing your own cherries are included below.

Author: Rebecca Lindamood

Ingredients

• Sweet Cherries (IQF frozen, pitted)

Instructions

1. To Individually Quick Freeze Cherries: Pit the cherries using a hand pitter, plunger pitter, or a pastry bag tip. Lay the pitted cherries on a rimmed baking sheet lined with foil or a silpat for easy removal. Freeze until solid. Once frozen, transfer the individual cherries into resealable zipper-top bags, squeezing out air, and label. Store in the freezer for up to a year.
2. Juicer Instructions (for soft-serve texture): Fit your whole-fruit juicer with a blank plate (not the juicing screen). Drop the frozen cherries into the hopper and use the tamper to guide them downward. The juicer will extrude a smooth, creamy soft-serve. Eat immediately for the best soft-serve consistency.
3. Food Processor Instructions (for soft-serve texture): Fit the work bowl of your food processor with a metal blade. Add frozen cherries to the work bowl and process until smooth. This may take a few minutes, with occasional scraping down the sides. Serve immediately for soft-serve. If the mixture becomes too liquidy, scrape it into ice cube trays and re-freeze. Once solid, drop the re-frozen cubes back into the food processor and pulse until smooth again.
4. Blender Instructions (for soft-serve texture): Add frozen cherries to the carafe of your powerful blender. Process until smooth, stopping occasionally to scrape down the sides and stir the contents as needed. This can be challenging with less powerful blenders. Serve immediately for soft-serve. If the mixture is too liquidy, scrape it into ice cube trays and re-freeze. After the cubes are re-frozen, drop them back into the blender carafe and pulse until smooth.
5. For Harder, Scoopable Ice Cream: If you prefer a firmer, scoopable ice cream texture, smooth the top of the freshly made fruit mixture, lay plastic wrap directly on the surface (to prevent freezer burn), and place it in the freezer for 30 minutes to an hour before serving.
6. What to Do with Leftovers: Any leftover one-ingredient ice cream can be poured or scraped into ice pop molds. Freeze them for fast, delicious, pure-fruit, and seriously healthy ice pops! These are ridiculously habit-forming!

Nutritional information is an estimate and provided to you as a courtesy. You should calculate the nutritional information with the actual ingredients used in your recipe using your preferred nutrition calculator.

Did you make this recipe?

Make sure to tag @foodiewithfam on Instagram and #hashtag it #foodiewithfamily so I can check it out!

Print Recipe
Pin Recipe
Share on Facebook

Frozen Treats Week and Exciting Giveaways!

Now, for an announcement I’ve been eager to share! I am participating in an exciting “Frozen Treats Week” alongside a group of fabulous food bloggers. We’ve all come together to celebrate summer’s chillest delights, and to make it even sweeter, we have some truly amazing prizes to give away to our readers. Today, we’re thrilled to feature an incredible prize package generously provided by Zoku and OXO.

Just look at that fantastic collection! Who wouldn’t want to win such an assortment of kitchen gadgets? I confess, I’m a bit green with envy because I covet every single item in that picture! I truly believe that leftover One-Ingredient Cherry Ice Cream and products from Zoku and OXO are a match made in heaven for creating delicious frozen treats. A huge thank you to both Zoku and OXO for sharing such fantastic prizes with our readers, making this “Frozen Treats Week” even more special.

While the original giveaway entry period may have passed, the spirit of “Frozen Treats Week” lives on through delicious recipes!

Looking for more frozen treat week recipes to inspire your summer?

• Mango Raspberry Pops from Katie’s Cucina
• Mango Margarita Boozesicles from Nutmeg Nanny
• Blood Orange Chocolate Popsicles from Rachel Cooks
• Cookies & Ice Cream Pie from Chocolate & Carrots
• Pineapple Mint Popsicles from Sweet Remedy
• 3-Minute Easy Cherry Chocolate Sorbet from An Edible Mosaic
• Chocolate Blueberry Crumble Pop from Cooking with Books
• Easy Frozen Cherry Pie from Cook the Story
• Bananas Foster Ice Cream from The Baker Chick
• White Chocolate Buttermint Ice Cream from Eats Well With Others
• Strawberry Cheesecake Popsicles from Damn Delicious

Big thanks go out to Nutmeg Nanny and Katie’s Cucina for organizing this generous extravaganza. We all win with great recipes for frozen treats to get us through the dog days and prize packs!

Disclaimer: This post is not sponsored by Zoku or OXO, and I did not receive product or payment to write this. Zoku and OXO did, however, provide one prize package for the giveaway associated with Frozen Treats Week.